Who is at Fault in a Car Accident

When you have a car accident it's vital to understand who is at fault. Know how fault is determined and the steps you should take.
How do i determine fault in a car accident?

Car Accident Determination Rules Australia

When you have had a car accident in Australia, determining who is at fault has consequences for legal liability. Determination of responsibility is often decided at the scene of the collision, so what you say and do at this time is vital to the outcome of any subsequent legal action. Motor vehicle accidents can cause severe financial and emotional consequences for all drivers involved in the collision.

A personal injury solicitor can help you through the process of filing a claim for injuries sustained in an auto accident, but it’s ultimately up to you to prove your case. A skilled injury lawyer can assist you during this stressful time. If something terrible happens to you in a car crash, here’s everything you need to know. For immediate support, Call Now – 1800 954 153 or email us >

More about car accident claims >

What is my claim worth?

Car Accident Determination Rules Australia icon

Determining Fault for a Collision

Determining fault for a collision relies on gathering and examining accident scene evidence. This could be photographs of vehicle damage, eyewitness accounts, records of auto repairs, witness testimony or law enforcement reports.

Ultimately, the third-party insurance company will decide who is to blame, and they typically attempt to assign some responsibility to the injury claimant to lower their liability (and your payout).

Hence, understanding the process of proving responsibility for a car accident helps improve your chance of getting the compensation you deserve. Please don’t stress if you were partly to blame for the collision. In this case, you would have contributory negligence, and your motor vehicle accident lawyer would seek to reduce your level of liability.

Fortunately, it’s simpler to know who is at fault when:

  • The other driver apologises, which is sometimes an admission of guilt.
  • The other road user is issued a traffic infringement (they are presumed to be at fault).
  • The type of accident impact helps determine who the at-fault driver was.

How to Determine Fault

The accident scene is the ideal location to determine fault. Someone else will likely be at fault if the police show up and a driver receives a ticket for speeding, ignoring traffic signals, intoxicated driving, or some other breach of road rules.

Otherwise, the common way of determining fault for an auto accident is to examine several factors, including:

  • Who initiated contact with whom?
  • What happened during the accident?
  • How did the accident happen?
  • Did anyone violate traffic laws?
  • Did the incident harm someone?

What should I do after a car accident? >

Free Online Claim Check

Why Determining Fault is Crucial

Defining the at-fault driver is essential for many reasons when you have a motor vehicle accident. First, if you have a collision, you want to know whether your actions made you liable for damages.

  1. You could face financial penalties and even criminal charges when you are at fault.
  2. If someone else caused the accident, you want to know how to proceed to avoid further damage to yourself or others.
  3. When injured in a car crash, knowing who is liable can help determine your legal entitlement to claim compensation.

Generally, each party is allocated fault at different levels when more than one person is shown to have accident liability. Hence, each party’s contribution level determines the value of damages.

Queensland Motor Accident Insurance Commission

According to the Queensland Motor Accident Insurance Commission, you can make a CTP insurance claim when you or your loved ones are harmed in a collision on QLD roads (that was partially or totally not your fault).

Proof of fault is necessary because it can affect how much money you receive in damages. If you are found responsible for the injury of another party, you could be liable for medical expenses, lost wages, pain, and suffering.

Evidence is Vital to Determining Fault.

Car accident fault is often challenging to prove because it depends on circumstantial evidence. There are often no witnesses to the incident and little physical evidence. Instead, the determination of responsibility must be shown through photographs, police records or other documents. Often, fault does not need to be proven beyond reasonable doubt but through clear and convincing evidence.

Who Decides Who is Responsible for an Auto Accident?

Most road crashes involve at least one driver, usually both drivers. The car insurer (typically the CTP insurance company) often determines the negligent party. An insurance provider employee may investigate the case. This report might include interviews with the drivers or other people involved in the crash and eyewitness accounts.

An insurance claim adjuster may also examine CCTV footage, a crime scene investigation report, and photos. In rare circumstances, the court will determine liability if the incident goes to court.

More about Queensland CTP claims >

What is No Win No Fee ?

Determining Fault Using Location of Vehicle Damage

A police officer or an insurance investigator can frequently decide what happened by viewing the vehicle damage after a road accident. Thankfully, modern technology has simplified the investigation process. For example, when police attend the scene, they can use:

  1. Marks on the road (like skid marks)
  2. Photographs of other vehicles’ positions
  3. And prevailing weather conditions

to determine the speed and direction of vehicles before impact.

Speed is another factor that can be used to determine the extent of vehicle damage. Higher speed = bigger impact = more damage. Other valuable information includes factors like:

  • did the airbags deploy
  • the position of the vehicles after the collision
  • the location of traffic lights and signs
  • mobile phone records (shows if the driver was texting)

A competent car accident law firm will assist you through the legal process of fault determination. Complex accidents can be particularly challenging, and the stakes can be high. Minimising your liability will be essential to the outcome of your claim for damages. Get legal advice now: Call 1800 700 125.

Why you need legal advice after a car accident >

Who is at fault when reversing?

Regardless of any other circumstance, you are inevitably at fault if you cause a rear-end collision. When moving backwards, you have a duty of care to ensure you don’t hit another vehicle or person. Under QLD Transport Operations (Road Use Management— Road Rules) regulation 2009, a motorist must not reverse their vehicle unless they can do it safely.

Who is at fault in a side-impact accident?

If your vehicle has side impact damage, this can assist in deciding who is legally liable. Suppose your car has been t-boned at an intersection with traffic lights or a stop sign, and the other vehicle has front-end damage. In that case, you can reasonably assume that the other driver committed a traffic violation and is at fault.

Who is to blame for a rear-end accident?

If the back end of your vehicle has been damaged in a rear-end accident, it is unlikely you have liability. Queensland Transport Operations (Road Use Management— Road Rules) s.126 states that all motorists have a legal duty to keep a safe distance between themselves and the vehicle in front. A possible exception is when someone migrates into another traffic lane with insufficient space and their car is struck at the back. Both drivers will be partly liable for the motor vehicle accident in this situation.

Who is at fault when turning right?

Oncoming traffic has priority at intersections in Queensland. Hence, you do not have the right of way when you stop at a t-intersection, regardless of whether it is a stop sign, traffic light, or no sign. When the light turns green, you acquire the right of way. When a collision happens at an intersection, the driver, without right of way, is responsible. Exceptions to this may be:

  • the other driver was exceeding the speed limit
  • the other driver changed lanes at the intersection
  • the accident was at night, and the other vehicle had faulty lights
  • the other driver was drunk
  • the other driver was using their phone

Who is at fault in a car park collision?

When an accident happens in a car park, the negligent driver is the one moving at the time of the accident. The driver of the moving vehicle has a duty of care not to strike another car or pedestrian. Generally, when both vehicles were in motion at the time of collision, a percentage of fault (contributory negligence) would be assigned to both drivers.

Who is at fault in a three-car collision?

Multi-vehicle accidents can be complex. The circumstances of the accident will determine who is responsible. If, for example, the incident happened in a concertina where each car rear-ended the other, you would be the liable party if you hit the vehicle in front (unless you were pushed from behind). Due to the complexity of multi-car collisions, several drivers will share a degree of fault.

Who is responsible for an accident in a hire car?

Unless an employee was driving, the hire car company is typically not responsible for damage caused while using their motor vehicle. However, this can change depending on the insurance policy type and the level of cover.

If someone other than the hirer is involved in the accident, you should seek legal advice immediately, as that person could be liable.

Free Online Claim Check

Steps to Determining Fault for a Car Accident

Don’t admit fault at the scene of the accident.

Sometimes, after an auto accident, people feel emotional and sensitive to the circumstances of the other parties involved. At this time, you might be tempted to apologise or admit your collision contribution. If you do this, you will decrease your legal position, which will have consequences for the outcome of any subsequent litigation.

Take note if the other party admits liability.

Conversely, if the other parties to the accident apologise or admit they caused the collision, you should note this immediately. People can admit liability in multiple ways, but often by apologising for:

  • Not seeing you
  • Running a red light
  • Distracted driving

If this happens to you, please use your phone to send an email to yourself noting their name, the date and time, and detailed notes of your conversation.

Lodge a Police Report

If law enforcement officers did not attend the accident scene, you should lodge a police report. If someone has a traffic infringement prosecution, they will automatically have increased liability (or total liability) for the road incident. Conversely, if you are issued with a traffic violation, a criminal lawyer may be able to reduce or revoke your ticket. In this situation, your liability would decrease.

Gather Sufficient Evidence

Evidence is vital for deciding road collision liability. Lawyers, insurers and the police use evidence for multiple purposes. So, collect as much as possible. This includes all accident participants’ names and contact details, vehicle registration numbers and insurers.

Be sure to record your speed, the time and date, the location of the accident and the weather conditions. Also, detail your perception of how the collision occurred and how you believe it happened. You might like to draw a diagram of the crash for future reference. Take copious photographs of the damage to vehicles, the accident scene, skid marks on the road, and any damage to your body.

If you have been physically or mentally harmed, you should also seek medical help, and your doctor, physiotherapist and psychologist should keep records of your condition and treatment.

Chat with Witnesses

Witness statements can help support your evidence. Be sure to get the contact details of anyone who can provide a comment. Ask them to give you a written account of how they believe the accident occurred and who they believe was at fault.

Get Legal Advice from Personal Injury Lawyers

When injured in a road accident, consulting with experienced personal injury lawyers is worthwhile. They will support you through the claims process, ensuring you have the evidence to build a compelling case. Splatt Lawyers will also help you determine your claim eligibility and your case’s approximate value. Contact us now for informed legal advice.

Do You Need Legal Help With Car Accident Liability?

Don’t rely on evidence from others involved in your road accident. Ensure you have a solid case to show you were either wholly or partly not at fault. When someone else fails to take reasonable care and you suffer a loss, you have the legal right to make a claim for compensation.

Determining fault and safeguarding your rights is complicated, especially when dealing with police reports and insurance policies. It helps to have experienced legal experts on your side.

Contact Splatt Lawyers to find out where you stand. All our legal compensation services are 100% no-win, no-fee. Starting costs nothing, and you pay nothing until we achieve a settlement. Call now for fast legal help—1800 700 125.

Get Started Now- It's Free

Car Accident Claim Lawyers Nearby

When you need to make a claim for a motor vehicle accident that was not your fault, it’s reassuring to know there are car accident compensation lawyers near you. Choose your location:

Gold CoastBrisbaneLoganIpswichToowoomba
Sunshine CoastTownsvilleCairnsCabooltureBundaberg
QLD Car Accident Lawyer Locations

Share this article :

Contact Us | Get a Call-back | Ask a Question

Latest News

Related News

What to do When Injured in an Uber Accident or Rideshare Crash
The Hidden Traps of No Win, No Fee in Queensland
How are Compensation Payout Amounts Calculated?