How to Sue Someone for Negligence Damages
If you suffered a physical or psychiatric injury from a car accident, a slip on a wet floor or due to medical malpractice, you may question whether you can sue for negligence. In Australia, you can start legal action to recover damages when harmed by a duty of care failure as long as you can show:
- The defendant owed a duty of care
- The defendant breached their common law duty
- Their negligence caused you a physical or psychiatric injury
- There was a related financial loss
Our legal guide explains the requirements for personal injury claims in Australia. Understanding the process of legal proceedings could help you claim compensation with less stress. So, continue reading to learn more about the laws relating to
- Liability, negligence, and malpractice
- You right to make a claim based on negligence
Free Consultation for Negligence Claims
Splatt Lawyers offers a free consultation for negligence claims to explain whether you have a valid claim, your potential compensation entitlements, and our legal costs.
All our legal services are funded on a 100% no-win, no-fee basis. Pay when you win and nothing if you lose. Call 1800 700 125
What is The Definition on Negligence for Common Law Claims?
- Negligence is a legal concept that refers to a person or party’s failure to exercise reasonable care in a given circumstance. It is a legal principle used in personal injury cases.
- In Australia, the law states that everyone has a general legal duty to take reasonable care to prevent foreseeable harm in most circumstances.
What is a Reasonable Person in Negligence Claims?
Although it may initially seem simple, negligence carries significant legal implications. At its core, negligence occurs when a reasonable person fails to exercise the level of care that a reasonable person would in the same circumstances.
- In other words, the defendant could reasonably foresee a substantial risk of loss and failed to take reasonable care for the safety of others.
- As a result of this breach of duty, the other party suffers a psychological or physical injury and a related financial loss.
Your Legal Right to Sue for Personal Injury in Queensland
In most circumstances, a person or party must take reasonable care to prevent harm from occurring to others. Because of this, you may have the legal right to sue for a personal injury and claim financial compensation when another party fails to take reasonable steps to ensure your safety.
When something goes wrong, the other party can be held liable. Here are some common examples.
Can I Claim Compensation for Negligence?
- You can sue for negligence when you suffer a personal injury because another person or party failed to take reasonable care to prevent foreseeable harm.
- Even if you were partly at fault for the incident that caused your loss, you can still successfully seek common law damages.
- Strict time limits apply to commencing legal action for personal injury matters.
- A personal injury lawyer can explain your rights under the Civil Liability Act and how to achieve a favourable outcome.
Common Types of Negligence Claims in Queensland
Type of Common Law Claim | Example |
|---|---|
Car accident claim for negligent driving | You can sue a negligent driver who causes a motor vehicle accident in any circumstance, e.g. driver, passenger, pedestrian, bike or motorcycle rider. |
Slip and fall claim | A person slips and falls in dangerous conditions like an uneven or wet floor, down stairs, etc. |
Medical negligence | A medical professional fails to provide the expected standard of medical treatment. |
Work injury damages claim | An employee could claim compensation when their employer fails to exercise reasonable care for their safety at work. |
Professional negligence claim | The injured party may seek compensation when a professional fails to take reasonable care when providing advice.
|
CTP insurance claims | You could lodge a claim against a CTP insurance company for the negligence of another road user. |
Free Claim Assessment
Professional negligence claims arise when a professional fails to exercise the reasonable care, skill, and competence expected in their field, resulting in harm or financial loss to a client.
They are often caused by the failure to disclose material risks, lousy advice, and mismanagement of investments or money.
This type of common law claim can be made against a wide range of service providers who owe a duty of care to their client, including:
- Lawyers
- Doctors
- Accountants
- Financial advisors
- Financial institutions
To make a successful professional negligence claim, the injured party must prove several key elements
- Prove that the professional owed a duty of care, which arises from the professional relationship between the parties.
- Prove that the professional breached this duty by failing to provide competent professional practice or not meeting the standard expected (or peer professional opinion).
- The claimant must have suffered a loss, such as a financial loss, physical harm, or mental harm.
In Queensland, professional negligence lawyers can provide independent legal advice following a breach of duty. They can explain your options and whether you have a valid claim.
Civil Liability Act 2003
The Civil Liability Act 2003 and common law protect the right to lodge personal injury claims in Queensland.
This legislation imposes an obligation to pay compensatory damages for the expenses incurred as a result of the defendant’s negligence.
- These legal guidelines and criteria are used to assess whether one party owed a legal duty and was negligent.
- These principles also rest on common law principles derived from earlier Australian court rulings.
What are the Four Pillars of a Negligence Claim?
The primary remedy for negligence is compensatory damages, which provide financial relief to the injured party for economic and non-economic losses. To achieve a successful outcome, you must prove four elements.
- Duty of care
- Breach of duty
- Causation
- Financial damages for the loss suffered
An experienced personal injury lawyer understands the requirements to receive fair compensation.
How to Determine if a Person Owes a Duty of Care
The’ duty of care’ concept is at the heart of every negligence case. This legal obligation requires everyone to act with due diligence to prevent foreseeable harm to others. But how do you know when a duty exists? And to whom is this duty owed?
What is a Legal Duty?
Essentially, a legal duty is a responsibility to prevent causing harm to others. The negligent party can be held liable when they fail to take reasonable care.
- This obligation emerges from the relationship or situation between the relevant parties.
- The relationship between the claimant and the defendant helps the court determine whether a particular duty exists in a negligence lawsuit.
However, there is no automatic duty of care for every person towards others. For an obligation to exist, a relationship must have a sufficient degree of closeness or proximity.
Who Can be Held Liable for Negligence?
- Most people have a legal duty to exercise appropriate care for the safety of others in most circumstances.
- Legal liability to pay negligence damages happens when there is a breach of duty. In other words, they failed to exercise reasonable care.
- They can then be held liable for the negligent act and the injured party can seek compensation
Common Examples of Duty-of-Care Relationships
Relationships that commonly result in a duty of care include the following:
- Property owners have a responsibility to keep their premises safe for all users.
- Landlords owe a duty of care to their tenants.
- Professionals such as lawyers, accountants, and financial advisors must provide competent advice and services.
- A doctor and patient relationship, as well as other medical professionals.
- Manufacturers must maintain safe product standards
- Employers must provide a safe working environment for their employees
-
Road users owe a duty of care to other drivers to avoid motor accidents
In Australia, an exception applies to ‘Good Samaritans’ when they act in good faith. Such people are released from civil liability when they assist during emergencies.
How to Identify a Breach of Duty (Proving Negligence)
After establishing a duty of care, the next step is proving negligence. Simply put, a duty breach occurs when one party does something a reasonable person would not do in the same circumstances.
What is Reasonable Care?
So, how do courts decide if a defendant has breached their duty of care? The court evaluates whether the defendant acted (or failed to act) with reasonable care, which differs from the ordinary prudence a careful person would have exercised in similar circumstances.
This evaluation considers the unique circumstances of a personal injury case, as every situation is unique.
Proving Causation and Harm
The next crucial aspect of a negligence case is establishing causation and harm. Hence, the plaintiff must prove the defendant’s conduct caused the injuries suffered by the claimant.
This step often considers the “but for” test. Would the injured party have been harmed regardless of the defendant’s actions? There must be both:
- A direct link, known as factual causation
- And legal causation – that the defendant should be held accountable.
The financial step in a personal injury case is assessing damages. In Australia, the calculation of compensatory damages considers both economic and non-economic losses.
Economic Loss Suffered Due to Negligence
Economic losses are included in compensatory damages for a negligence claim, including the following:
- Past and future medical expenses
- Lost wages and superannuation
- Travel-related treatment costs
- Cost of home care and domestic services
- Other out-of-pocket expenses
- Assessing damages for economic loss involves a complex process of estimating the actual financial harm to the person making a claim due to the defendant’s carelessness.
- Total damages can also consider future financial losses like lost earning capacity and future medical expenses.
Non-Economic Loss (General Damages)
On the other hand, non-economic loss refers to non-financial damages, such as pain and suffering or emotional distress. These losses are subjective and can vary greatly from person to person.
For example, two people may suffer the same injury in a car accident. Still, their experiences of pain and suffering could be vastly different, making each person’s injury unique.
Non-economic losses are determined through a subjective assessment based on the case’s circumstances and include the following:
- Pain and suffering compensation
- Lost enjoyment of life
- Impact of long-term or permanent disability
- Disfigurement
Common Defences Against Negligence Claims
You can improve your chance of making a successful negligence claim if you understand the common defences against this type of lawsuit. Common tactics insurance companies use to defend these cases typically involve:
- Disputing the elements of negligence
- Showing a lack of causation
- Alleging that you partially contributed to the incident (called contributory negligence).
Disputing these elements involves questioning whether:
- The negligent party owed a duty of care
- They breached that duty
- The injury suffered was caused by the duty breach
- You suffered a financial loss as a result
What is Contributory Negligence?
Another common legal defence is that the defendant’s negligence helped cause the accident. This is called contributory negligence. This legal principle holds that you helped cause the injuries suffered in an accident.
- Insurance companies often attempt to assign a level of contributory negligence to a claimant to reduce the value of financial compensation.
- An experienced personal injury lawyer knows how to negotiate down the level of contribution to deliver a better outcome.
How to Make a Negligence Claim
Filing a lawsuit for common law damages (suing for negligence) follows an ordered process. Here are the steps:
Get Medical Attention
First seek medical attention for your injury or illness. This step creates a medical record and begins the recovery process.
Collect Evidence
Next, you need to collect evidence to support a personal injury claim. These documents can include:
- Photos and videos of the accident scene that show property damage
- Police and medical reports
- Witness statements
- Maintenance and accident reports
Legal Advice from a Personal Injury Lawyer
- Seeking independent legal advice before starting legal action for damages suffered is your legal right.
- A compensation lawyer can help you understand the process of legal proceedings and your rights
- They can explain your eligibility to seek compensation and determine the best course of action for your circumstances
Lodge a Civil Claim
The next step in claiming compensation for a serious injury is to lodge a personal injury claim form with the liable insurance company.
Settlement Negotiations
Settlement negotiations begin once one party accepts liability for the injuries suffered by the claimant. Once approved, they may receive compensation for:
- Medical expenses
- Lost wages
- Pain and suffering
- Lost quality of life
- Travel and out-of-pocket expenses
Court Proceedings
Most negligence claims settle without going to court. In rare cases, further legal action may be taken, and a court determines the outcome.
The Role of Insurance Companies in Common Law Claims
The liable insurance company typically funds a lump sum payout when you have a successful common law claim. How your incident occurred determines the type of insurance claim. For example:
- When you are injured in a public space or on private property, you make a public liability claim.
- CTP insurance claims apply to most traffic accidents
- For work-related injuries, you make a WorkCover claim for workers’ compensation benefits
- Medical negligence: you sue the doctor, the medical centre or the hospital’s liability insurance provider.
Strict Time Limits to File a Personal Injury Claim
Strict time limits apply to taking legal action for negligence. The time limit for claiming damages arising from personal injuries will depend on your type of claim and the applicable legislation. These time limits, known as statutes of limitations, set the deadline for filing a negligence claim.
The general time limit for most personal injury claims is three years from the date of the accident, with some rare exceptions.
- For example, if the injured person was younger than 18 at the time of the incident.
- Missing a deadline often means being excluded from filing a damages lawsuit.
- There can be some rare exceptions in certain circumstances
Professional negligence claims have a general time limit of six years, or three years if they involve psychological or physical harm.
Vicarious Liability in Negligence Claims
Vicarious liability in negligence cases is most often associated with the relationship between employer and employee. Consequently, an employer is responsible for the conduct of their workers. So if you are injured at work, and your employer breaches their duty of care, they can be vicariously liable for their worker’s careless actions or failure to act.
This legal concept allows the claimant to lodge a case against multiple defendants, which can increase the chance of a compensation payout. You must be aware of this type of liability, regardless of whether you are a business owner, worker or claimant.
Suing for Personal Injury Damages FAQs
Can I sue for negligence at work?
If you suffer personal injuries at work and your employer is the negligent party, you may have the legal right to sue them under the Queensland workers’ compensation scheme.
This legal action is known as a common law claim.
Can I sue for medical negligence?
- In Australia, a doctor, hospital, medical centre and medical professionals have a legal duty to provide sufficient medical care.
- When they fail this duty and suffer a loss, you may have the legal right to sue for common law damages.
What happens when you sue someone for negligence?
- When you sue someone for negligence, you seek common law damages to compensate for any financial losses caused by the other person’s negligent actions.
- The purpose of financial compensation is to restore the injured party to their pre-incident state.
How do you prove negligence?
- To prove negligence, you must show that a duty was breached, causing harm or damages that a reasonable person could have prevented.
- This standard is generally applied when someone acts carelessly and injures another person.
Can you sue for punitive damages in Australia?
Australian courts typically do not award damages as punishment (known as punitive damages).
- They may grant punitive damages in rare cases where someone intentionally inflicts harm or shows a lack of respect for someone else’s rights.
- In this case, you would receive compensation that exceeds the value of an actual loss.
What are contemptuous damages?
Contemptuous damages can be awarded by a court after unsuccessful legal proceedings. They indicate the court’s disapproval of a legal action that:
- Has no merit
- Is frivolous
- Should not have been brought at all
What is meant by sue for damages?
Suing for damages refers to a legal action to recover financial compensation for an injury suffered due to the negligence of others.
Who can be held liable for negligence?
Any individual, organisation, or entity can be held liable for negligence if they owe a duty of care and breach it (causing foreseeable harm).
Common examples include:
- Work injuries caused by your employer
- Car accidents caused by drivers and other roads
- Professional negligence by lawyers, accountants and medical professionals
- Negligence by local councils and property owners
What are aggravated damages?
Aggravated damages are a specific type of compensatory damages that can be awarded in civil lawsuits.
- A court may award additional compensation (above the normal payout amount) when the injured party has suffered additional emotional distress or humiliation due to the circumstances giving rise to the lawsuit.
- They can be granted when the defendant’s conduct was particularly malicious or egregious, e.g. intentionally inflicting harm.